Watch CBS News

4 Men Charged With Murders In Douglas County


CASTLE ROCK, Colo. (CBS4)- Four men remain in jail Thursday night. They were formally charged with the murders of two people in Douglas County.

The bodies of Amara Wells, 39, and her brother-in-law

amara-wells
Amara Wells (credit: Facebook)

Robert Rafferty, 49, were discovered Wednesday, Feb. 23 by Wells' 6-year-old daughter. The girl ran to a neighbor's house for help and reported finding her mom and uncle on the floor, with blood.

bob-rafferty
Bob Rafferty (credit: Facebook)

Christopher Wells, 49, Josiah Sher, 26, Matthew Plake, 26, and Micah Woody, 29, were in court Thursday afternoon. All four waived the formal reading of charges, which means those charges are now sealed with the court documents.

According to Douglas County Jail, Wells is facing charges of first degree murder, criminal solicitation, conspiracy, violations of bond and protection order. Wells is the estranged ex-husband of Amara Wells.

christopher-wells
Christopher Wells appeared in court in Douglas County on Thursday. (credit: CBS)

Sher is facing first degree murder, assault, arson, burglary and conspiracy charges.

josiah-sher
Josiah Sher appeared in court in Douglas County on Thursday. (credit: CBS)

Woody is facing first degree murder, criminal solicitation and conspiracy charges.

micah-woody
Micah Woody appeared in court in Douglas County on Thursday. (credit: CBS)

Plake is facing a charge of first degree murder.

matthew-plake
Matthew Plake appeared in court in Douglas County on Thursday. (credit: CBS)

Sher, Woody and Plake were arrested over the weekend for the murders of Rafferty and Amara Wells. Christopher Wells has been in custody since the day before the murders on suspicion of violating a restraining order after he allegedly sent hundreds of text messages to his ex-wife.

Wells' attorney raised an issue in court on Thursday afternoon.

"All of the defendants are currently being housed here, there are only two visitation rooms available. We are fighting for opportunities to see our clients," said Wells' Attorney Tina Tussay.

A status hearing is set for March 18 for all four defendants.

Investigators said they have not ruled out the possibility others were involved in the murders.

Additional Resources

Bodies Found Inside Douglas County Home Identified

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.