Top Apple Pie In Denver

September 4, 2013 6:00 AM


Pie (credit: Mermaid’s Bakery)

There is something about the crisp start of fall that calls for a freshly baked apple pie. Tart Granny Smith apples blanketed in a buttery crust is pure comfort food for autumn. Denver’s best pie bakeries add caramel fillings to the American lexicon of desserts, while still others grate in sharp cheddar cheese to the crust. And all can provide pies for your holiday parties. Get your fix at these Denver-area spots.

Humble Pie Store
300 Elati St.
Denver, CO 80223
(720) 479-8690

Humble Pie opened in October 2012 and it’s been opening eyes as to what a great pie can be ever since. At Humble Pie, the apple pie is far from humble. The shop takes a lesson from New England pie lovers with sweet and tart baked apples, topped with a sharp cheddar lattice. If you prefer your apple pie through a straw, try the pie shakes made with Sweet Action ice cream. Pies are available by the slice, a five-inch round or a whole pie.

Wednesday’s Pies
1422 Larimer St.
Denver, CO 80202
(303) 893-6505

Wednesday’s Pies is a basement pie shop with a compact space and generous flavors. The pie shop used to be open only on Wednesdays but now pie lovers can partake any day they have a pie craving. Wednesday’s Pies typically only has three pies, one an apple caramel with Tart Granny Smith apples cloaked in a sweet caramel sauce. Executive chef Tim Murphy adds almond flour to a butter crust to give the pastry a little something extra. The other pie flavors vary but fan favorites include Oreo cream pie, a cream pie chocked full of Oreos and topped with finely crushed Oreos. It’s a bit like the childhood dirt cakes or mud pies. Another favorite pie is the ricotta pineapple, with a creamy and tropical pineapple filling.

Related: Top Caterers in Denver

Granny Scott’s Pie Shop

3333 S. Wadsworth Blvd.
Lakewood, CO 80227
(303) 986-6240

If you are looking for a pie shop that reminds you of days gone by, Granny Scott’s Pie Shop will take you back. Granny’s has a few apple pies to choose from: a caramel apple with a wrap-around crust, a Dutch apple with a streusel topping and a sugar-free apple. Granny’s also has another two-dozen pie flavors, house-made fudge and pecan rolls, as well as savory pies and a lunch menu. All complete meals include a soft drink and a slice of pie.

Mermaid’s Bakery
1543 Champa St.
Denver, CO 80202
(303) 534-0956
www.mermaidsbakery.comYear after year, Mermaid’s is recognized as a local favorite for cupcakes, cakes and pies. The bakery doesn’t skimp on pure high-quality ingredients or flavor. The apple pie is for purists, with tart apples and a flaky crust. The pies are available in a mini-size and full size. Order ahead of time for special orders and for holidays. Check out the cupcakes while you are in the shop – salted caramel, butter pecan and cinnamon churro are just a few tempting flavors.

Editor’s Note: A store featured on this list has since closed. The Shoppe, used to be located at 3103 East Colfax Ave.

Kimberly Lord Stewart is a food author and journalist for CBS Denver local, Organic Food Reporter for, and the Food, Wine and Spirits editor for Denver Life magazine. Her book, “Eating Between the Lines” tells readers about the truth and myths of food labeling. Stewart is the recipient of two Association of Food Journalist awards for food news reporting and the Jessie Neal Business Journalism award. Her work can be found at